And The Rest…


So I had a plan to how this blog would continue… the next title was to be CHERYL#1 and bring us back into those final comments on LISK.com that I first had stumbled on to in February. I was gonna write about how Chery#1 seemed to be the one who tried to really stay out of the finger-pointing and name calling and would try to keep things on topic. But as I have commented, stuff came out of the games as well and Cheryl#1 seemed to be able to separate and discuss what was important without going off on those who were deemed “spreading misinformation”. Not that Cheryl#1 did not comment on people being suspicious with the info they had (such as Flukeyou). But Cheryl seemed (to me at least) try to stay above the drama without constantly complaining about the drama like others did. This would have then brought me to M.D. Rice and Linda. Which would have came first, I’m not sure, because honestly I was worried about Linda’s. I knew it was gonna seem harsh. So I probably would have ended Cheryl#1 leading into the sometimes arguments that Cheryl#1 and M.D.Rice would get into. Then next would have titled

M.D.RICE and I would have written about M.D.Rice someowhat take on the case (which is a little confusing because they never could really fully comment  on their ideas, but I believe it had something to do with a professional hit man with a personal vendetta of some sort. Which I would have then gone into how that makes me thing of Fluke and the other “gangster names” said to have lived in OB. Then on to how some like Cheryl#1 suspected M.D.Rice was a fake screen name or not who they claim to be or something like this, I have not yet gone back to reread and get the whole jist of it, and since I’m not continuing the blog in this manner there is no need to at this moment figure out M.D.Rice. But I do know I would have ended that blog discussing why commenters like Cheryl#1 and others saw things in M.D.Rice’s comments but could not see what I saw in Linda’s comments. Which would have made the next blog called

LINDA, (edited since original post) Linda’s comments seemed to be contradicting.  She could be nice and friendly but then could also be pretty harsh. From feeling foolish to suddenly ranting on and on about others.  Linda was not the only one to call names, but hers could be like I said, harsh. Next would have been

PS149 which would have been cool, cause PS149 has recently joined us here in comments. I mainly would have had questions about comments PS149 made and why they were so sure (if they did not know him personally) KNOW CPH was innocent. I would have also brought my belief that PS149 and Too Close Too Home did not seem like the same person to me, but I wondered if they didn’t know each other in RL. I would have then bought it full circle to

MYSTERYMOM7 and about how I felt about her being stalked, which I have said again and again is a CRIME and not a GAME and she needs to keep up on it till some one is held responsible, I would have also gone into how, like other’s, I could see how the possible influence from Flukeyou could be distracting some of her ideas and so on and so forth, but again why go on about it now right?

Then it would have been time for some kind of ending… but what? I mean I haven’t shown anything that most of you don’t already know… the TRUTH will come out or it won’t… hopefully the CPH trial will answer some questions, but maybe it won’t. As I have always said, hopefully this case gets solved SOON!  For the victims and the families, this is what NEEDS to be done. And also as I have said I am not in any position but to ask questions when it comes to the LISK case. But I could see through some of these comments on LISK.com and thought I could get a better understanding by blogging about it, and I did. But proving anything is impossible. At least for me. I can only speculate, and as of yesterday, I realized that would help no one reading this blog. Only myself. And that would defeat the whole reason I started blogging.

But we still have to have some sort of ending…

So bear with me…

just a little bit longer.



Before I move on looking at comments left on LISK.com, I know that many think that this is just more distraction from the real case and justice for the victims. I want to make clear that my interest is what brought me to LISK.com and not the other way around. And as I have shown, these games of misdirection and finger-pointing has been going on at LISK.com for a long time. I just started reading it in February of this year, but looking back there are tons of comments accusing others of not caring about the victims, and not helping the victims, and hurting the victims.

I don’t know if the victims or their families are being hurt by any of this. Although I do understand that some of these screen names have been involved with the families to some extent, so I’m sure they know who the helpful ones are by now and who is spreading misdirection, maybe, but maybe not. I don’t know. But as for my involvement and this blog… I stated from the beginning that this was to find the truth behind the comments and not to catch a serial killer. But I think if you are honest you can’t help but see, that getting to the truth behind LISK.com comments can and will help the victims, even if it’s just to show that there are people out there that are misrepresenting their involvement in this case.

So if you truly care about the victims, then you should see that my wanting to seek out the truth behind all these comments and inside information still can help the victims and their families. But in my humble opinion, it is the authorities that owe it to the victims to make sense of this mess and do their job and solve this case or cases. I’ll leave you, for now, with all your own words. Did you mean them?

I agree with Wanda. I stand for the victims and their families and part of that pledge is bringing tranparancy and clarity to the investigation. Maddalena is not my real name but I do not use other names to further confuse or mix up. In defense of Cheryl 2, I think that her heart is in the right place and just happens to be her name of choice but has since made amends.

Maddalena on January 6th, 2012 at 11:35 am


That is very true,Linda. And that is the most important thing. We all want justice for the victims.

M.D. Rice on February 20th, 2013 at 8:33 pm


THIS IS EXACTLY WHAT THEY WANT…please stop guys!! totally not important argument in the big picture?? hello?? THE VICTIMS??

linda on February 21st, 2013 at 8:25 pm


 Most important, it just isn’t fair to the victims to have these sick individuals demanding that searching for the real killer(s) by giving the false hope of the incorrect accusation of who the LISK is. Anyone who really cares about seeking justice for the victims will understand how important it is to keep an open mind and not let the words of a few diseased minds stop anyone from looking for the real killer. The victims deserve justice. They deserve much more than having an innocent man framed for their murders while the real killer walks the streets ready and able to kill again.

For the sake of the victims, trust nothing you see written or said that cannot be verified. For the sake of the victims, do not let one man’s personal vendetta stop you from looking for the real LISK.

ps149 on February 27th, 2013 at 6:09 pm

All Been Said Before

Leave a comment

so, this is one way it is done. Create a false enemy, and get your victim to believe you share this in common. Then the victim lets you in under the guise of defeating the enemy. The enemy is right there next to you pointing their finger. Isn’t that so, crappy? Borderline much?

VeryReal on January 13th, 2012 at 2:08 am


@Very Real-You took the words that I could not say right out of my mouth. I suspect the reason for people posting under multiple names is that they have support from what appears to be other posters regarding their theory. I much rather debate with those who disagree than deal with creepiness esp those who are one individual who post interchangebly under female and male guises.Makes me wonder what else they are capable of. I think the killer can be found on this site or perhaps his lacky associates.

Maddalena on January 13th, 2012 at 1:53 pm


i wish some of you cooks that talk in riddles,and keep accusing people would stop it. your giving me a damn head ache.can’t even read good post cause of your shit.if your not here to help just leave.you sound like a bunch of kids, that your parents need to pay attention to what you pull up on your pc.stop insulting ppl.stop talking about ppls chin hairs,how fat they are…etc.. none of this has anything to do with this case so why say it,other than to be a immature brat.and if you continue the admin needs to block your ip address.have a great day.

wanda on January 7th, 2012 at 1:08 pm


What Mari said is what I meant by compromised. Some people here have “fly on the wall” information and I have to question exactly how they came by it.
And Sybill, I mean Sophia, used this thread to drop hints until we can came to the conclusion that best suited “her” agenda.
If these insiders have gone to Law Enforcemen then what’s their point here? We are honestly interested in the case but we are not pawns.

Cheryl on August 22nd, 2011 at 6:34 pm


Cheryl, I say keep em talkin and discern for yourself. I can tell nothing bogus is going to get passed you woman. You’re really sharp. So is Mari and the others. Im curious as to why anyone would waste precious moments of his or her life to deceive others on a discussion board and it really makes you wonder…I’m referring to Sybil and others who have stopped by to chat.

The Nasty on August 22nd, 2011 at 8:39 pm


@too close to home

I’ve been reading the two of you since the beginning…back and forth,back and forth…..Its not about the 2 of you.
Theres a poster on the other website saying similar things….are you over there busting his chops too every time he posts something?
I don’t know for sure if CPH is a killer;But he is a proven pathological liar.Definitely One of my POIs as far as involvement goes.And my opinion is not based on what Fluke says.You have to admit that things don’t look so good for CPH.
TS has done some great sleuthing on CPH on the other site…and those are FACTS.
The things Fluke posts about just happened to have been True,regardless of how he knows.
You’re the only one here (or anywhere,for that matter) that doesn’t want Fluke to talk.
So far, I know you’ve been right about one thing…..This is NOT a game.
LE is still on the case and still questioning people….
So if you have information (that are facts) about Fluke,then I suggest you meet with the detectives.
If you care so much for the victims and their families…go out there and bring some new information to the site.CPH isn’t the only POI out there being dicussed.
The other site has an abundance of interesting factual information about other questionable characters.If you want to talk research.
Speaking of FACTS…you still didn’t answer…
How do you KNOW Fluke is lying?
How do you KNOW CPH isn’t involved in any way?

BTW….for someone doesn’t know CPH…you sure get worked up.

Puzzled on March 10th, 2012 at 6:08 pm

These comments and many others, like mine, not trying to figure out the LISK case but trying to figure out LISK.com. What is the purpose here? How many are just outsiders sucked in? How many have inside info because they are involved in the case? Who’s being tricked and who’s really doing the tricking? And WHY?  Always back to this. Why is this ongoing finger-pointing game going on for so long on this site?

I heard the site had closed down once before and I found this comment left by admin:

please do not argue. we already closed the site because of people being argumentative. it is okay to express how you feel about this subject but do not attack other members of the site.

admin on March 1st, 2012 at 12:48 pm

This seems to simplify it way too much. A lot more than arugmenting was going on…

Who’s Who?


i am tired of these users using false names,acting crazy under others names.trying to use others names to say stuff that person would not say.please vote here on,making it a 1 user per-name site.and possible a 1 user per ip address site.or 1 user per email address.maybe this will put a halt to the mayhem.
all that agree please vote yes,all that dont agree vote no.
admin. please take this very heavily in your decision.

In this post  Wanda left in  January 2012 on LISK.com, it seems clear that the question of someone using more than one screen name was an ongoing thing on LISK.com:

Just a warning, Jury has been rather quite…
So that means that he is still here… he has just switched screen names….
I’ll have that info shortly….                        

NO WAY!!! on February 7th, 2012 at 10:50 am


@ Jenny,
I can tell you for a fact that Im not Jury……I just started posting here,and somehow I knew this would happen.I hesitated to post here because of so many being accused of posting as someone else….Maybe some are but Im not….And no I dont Live on Long Island,Im over 1500 miles away,but my husband was told that they may get the recovery contract after Irene,and I fallow him,so I was a bit concerned about a serial Killer being on the Loose….. Im just praying that this sick person/s are caught….so that the victums can Rest In Peace..And their familes can have Justice…

SouthernBelle on February 7th, 2012 at 4:07 pm


Mr. Pooper Scooper,
Cappy…..loves caps…Weirdo Hats
You got to be kidding…..Whats your real screen name Very Real???????Barnaby…………Ken??????/Caddie?????

You make me laugh you are a BIG FAKE…..How’s the ZOO life????? Cleaning up Poop all day must get aggravating……so I guess creating a super Hero persona is almost understandable

How about a trailer trash cook book??????? To go with that lifestyle of yours.

The peach fuz chin…..whats that about, Speak of heavy…OMG….Dirty Looking …..Dumpy more like it…..Basically jumped into a dumpster to dress….but nothing fits….real Raunchy

I won’t reveal your license plate or your address like you do to others……You are a discusting FAKE.Go jacuzzi/hot tub your clothes…the stink is unbearable.

You ever here that saying CRACK KILLS……pull up your dumpy Huge jeans as your backside SMELLS. Balding head grasps for straws with tiny side burns & straggly gross strangly chin hair.

If targeting posters putting out peoples private info makes you feel Superior (cuz thats what you do) you get the info from Mari …..using whatever means you can, this is not being a detective…..it’s honestly taking advantage of people with a genuine concern. Why try to inflict fear????? on others, why Caddies Gus Coletti talk as though he is on edge of his porch just waiting to legitimately shoot someone.

This is the atmosphere you & peudeo’s names create….very consistant

Now give the Sight back to the families Mr. Elephant Man…..hoping to get fame & spot light attention from them….You deserve nothing so don’t even start about how important you are.

They may have not noticed you are a LEECH yet….But they will.

To me I see you as a discusting, grave robber…….who thinks everybody owes him….just like the book writer…..Do you know anything about the film someone is trying to make..probably a ploy by Serial Killer…..


Jury Box on January 7th, 2012 at 11:45 am


haha that ones a kook and i would never respond to it!im not new ive been posting for a while now.always under jenny sooooo quite insulting to me if you can even entertain that i am the jury kook.anyway i am one of the minority on this board being that i live here and none of you do.it truly amazes me that there are so many people outside of long island that has taking an intrest to this case.believe me people here could care less!most people i talk to barely knows we have a serial killer right under our noses!!!

jenny on February 7th, 2012 at 7:08 am

So Barnaby Jones  and  Jim (who I’m guessing is Jim Jones) are Fluke supporters. Are they Fluke? And what about jenny? She said she lived there and thanks Truthspider for turning her on to the book supposed to be about CPH’s childhood. Is she Fluke? And what about NO WAY!!! ?

And then on the other side we have mcme. Definitely not a fan of Fluke’s.  Then there are others like The Foreigner. I did not read any posts made by The Foreigner but many comments about them, so they must have ruffled some feathers on one side or the other.

But looking at older posts one commenter seems to not trust ither side, and it didn’t seem like anyone trusted hers. Jury Box…

Caddie YOU ARE LYING!!!!!!!


So stop with the NONSENSE……You are not believed

Nobody on this Sight has a pass card….that is what serail killers look for. Trust from innocent…..NO ONE HERE IS TO BE BELIEVED as to who they are.

People use others identity….try & achieve sending a virus to a poster to track steal passwords, banking & even posting as…..

This sight is a non secured…That Says It All people. You knopw what you are getting into….

Mingling with Residents from Oak Beach & most likely Joesph Brewer The Serial Killer Himself…IMO

So every1 knows the big game on here
Reveal or use screen name….whatever…there are no rules..here

They make them when the crossed a serious boundary than they do not inforce

Jury Box on January 7th, 2012 at 12:16 pm


Wait… now who is Caddie?

Joey Scalice Jr.


I’m not here to try and change anybody’s opinion, only to offer mine. I’ve also seen the video of JS jr.acting,believe it or not, more reserved than normal while dealing with a neighbor. He must have known the cameras were on. He’s a guy with some serious anger problems. I don’t consider that a video of a resident acting poorly towards a victims family member.
Jenny, please be aware that I’ve been following this story since it began and have watched all the shows, read all the stories and seen all the videos. I’ve also lurked around on a few different web sites that discuss it.
NO WAY, sorry you got a bad impression of OB. As far as the property value argument, most people I know wouldn’t leave the beach for all the money in the world.
People are not always going to see things the same way, and should be able to discuss why they see the same thing differently, without it turning into an attack on anyone. Not that I feel at all attacked, or feel that I’ve attacked anyone.
mcme on February 8th, 2012 at 3:35 pm 

The first mentions of Joey all seem to be about an Oak Beach resident who is seen on the News.  Mentions of J.S. Jr. on the news with neighbor Gus. I did not see these news programs, I do not know who J.S. Jr. is, but due to so many early posts of him on the news and the mentions of him being a neighbor in Oak Beach, leads me to believe the Scalice Family lived in the gated community.  This is why I’m not capable to really sleuth this case, I don’t even know if the Scalice family lived in Oak Beach, but again, many comments from different sleuthers  say that they were.

And from the beginning it seems there were some people on the site that thought Flukeyou was Joey. And I’m guessing MM7 knew (or thought) Flukeyou was Joey. Yet even when PS149 accused Flukeyou of being Joey (at the time I thought this was a new accusation, now I know it has been going on for a while) there is still some hesitation for anyone to come right out and say Flukeyou is Joey, even though everyone seems to know this.

If Joey is Flukeyou a lot makes sense and a lot more can be focused on. So Joey has reasons to target CPH and has been on sites using different screen names ( I believe Too Close had noticed on at least one post I read where Fluke forgot to change his name Brendan before posting). I also think Flukeyou was behind some of the comments on MM7s blog, like Gus and Barbra H., but that’s just my opinon. But the Brendan thing confuses me because then who is Brendan/Truthspider. They seem to be 2 different people connected maybe through something to do with lifeguards. So why was Flukeyou posting under his buddies name?

What I’m getting at is there are screen names on both sides that seem may be connected to A. Flukeyou or B. Too Close Too Home. And a lot of these screen names had already stopped posting before I started reading. Did they stop posting or did they change screen names or were they just retired sock puppets?