Confusion or More Games


Well I’d like to get back to the Summer of 2011 and other screen names, but this JJ one has found some road blocks. As Cristin commented, Jen has said she used the screen name jj when on LISK.com. And this JJ is easily confused with it. I myself had to rewrite that last post 3 times because of the confusion. But I do see that there is a JJ and a jj commenting in the month of April. I have posted the JJ ones (see last post) which I believe come from Jim Jones, they speak of CPH and going to LE. Now the jj’s I found in April are as follows:


Now I think confusion solved, 2 different screen names, just similar enough to be seen as the same. JJ comments on who the killer is and jj comments on how the site needs to focus on positive helpful things rather than where it is going. So one could easily say we found Jim Jone’s first comments as well as Jen’s.

Accept Jen has just written me telling me none of these are hers, JJ is Jim Jones and this jj is someone pretending to be her.


Why was someone trying to be Jen so early on, and why can’t I find any earlier postings by jj?  There would need to be in order for someone to think there was a reason to pretend to be her. And why pretend to be Jen just to write about how the site is changing?

Regardless Jen insists she did not write these and does not want me or any of the comments to associate them with her.

So be it, common sense aside, here is a look at the first known fake screen name, pretending to be Jen  already in April of 2011.

Sorry if this has lost you, it’s hard to explain any clearer than this.

Right from the beginning games being played.

Let’s move on, and back to the Summer of 2011. Let’s see if we can find some other first comments.


The Problems With Writing This Blog


The 3 main problems with writing this blog were always:

#1. This is a real ongoing unsolved case, which means there are family and friends of the victims that are still hoping and looking for answers and don’t need more people who do not have them putting their 2 cents in. This also means LE are still actively looking into this and related cases and also don’t need more Google Detectives mucking up investigations and wasting time. I’ve done my best to treat this as the most important part of this blog, not getting into the case, but it has not been easy.

#2. Those who post comments with questionable TMI. With so many comments including things about people (some of which I am not even sure these people exist. For example I don’t know Dorothy’s Husband’s ex-wife. How could I know if such a person is real.) So what to allow in comments is hard, I have quite a bit I took off or didn’t allow.

#3 How fast everything changes. If you read this from the beginning, you know that many blogs changed or were removed, ideas for blogs changed long before I could finish them or in some cases even start them. When I first started thinking for names for the blog I thought it was going to be to expose a group of people playing games with a house wife sleuther in Florida or maybe even a serial killer stalking her. But with the arrival of PS149, and the back n forths that came on LISK.com leading up to it being removed told me my blog would not be what I thought it would be. And these things kept happening through out writing this blog making it very unpredictable and very time-consuming. I did my best to read all blogs and comments related which became harder each day since they were being removed so often. Yes changes all around made it very difficult to keep up and keep things straight.  This also meant that important issues never even got brought up. And back in the beginning when people and posts started disappearing stated I went back and read as much old posts I could find on LISK.com. In these early readings there was familiar screen names like Flukeyou, Too Close Too Home, MDRice, Wanda, Cheryl, and a few others, and screen names I had heard mentioned in comments, like Truthspider , Jury Box, Barnaby Jones, Jim Jones (2 Jones) etc. And the more I read back the more things changed on my take of what was happening.

So although these 3 problems will I’m sure continue to make writing this blog difficult and time-consuming, I feel it is not finished and at least some answers might be there if we take another look and a few of you decide to start REALLY helping get to the truth.

From the beginning I felt something strange and diabolical might be going on in the posts and comment on LISK.com. And I had only been reading there for a couple months before it was removed.

Those reading and commenting for years knew it was much more than some online sleuthers arguing over what they think happened in a case they read about. People commenting here knew things. And behind the scenes people were sharing information and misinformation. Teams were being picked. That may a little too black n white but there was definitely a Flukeyou vs. CPH feel from quite early in the readings and people definitely were dividing into camps.

It is questionable if CPH has ever been involved in any comments or posts on LISK.com or any other related site or blog, but some believe he has been, or at least say they do.  As for Flukeyou, he posted quite a bit. and I think it’s safe to say everyone knows Flukeyou is Joe Scalice Jr. and it is also safe to say everyone knows the many different reasons for the Scalices to hold grudges against their neighbors and/or former neighbors.

This last paragraph speaks volumes if you are listening.

Buy again it may be to black n white. I don’t want to sound like a conspiracy theorist, but there seems to be more going on here then an old grudge. And more than just Jr. commenting on LISK.com.

So shall we take a look… a real good look at LISK.com before we get into its commenters.

Jury Box

1 Comment

My Theory,
 Very Real, Caddie, Jim Jones, 2C2H are only here to chase away innocent people looking for justice….You Hi-Jack the sight….inflict fear to those you may feel are weak..Thats SADIST, Joking via causing harm, putting out peoples info is going to get one in serious trouble.
Harm is used on here daily as well as words like: IDIOT< STUPID MENTALLY ILL< FAT<
 I feel for people if they buy into the bullying tactic to which you run the sight with.
 Joesph Brewer in my opinion has tortured, Murdered, mislead, Killed, all these young girls plus I bet at least 20 to 30 more….starting in the 1980’s.
 Along they way what better to get friendly with the nieghbors than having them invite to a girl night…….Than bringing a group to answer……Use his Nieghbors but tangle them so tight in his web….they have been guilty to of crimes ………maybe The Doctor knew about a few victims……,GC please I bet he has used escorts regularly…..shaving & getting dressed when Shannan goes banging on door?????
 Makes sense if he just got back from Joesphs party or maybe thats were JB went to have GC serviced..
Why else would Gus be up….car show NOWAY…Bu**shit
Viagra………Bet he didn’t open the door because she was already with him….
 Theory….Thats what this sight is about
Jury Box on January 7th, 2012 at 12:01 pm

So here, again we see that LISK.com has been was stuck on repeat for a while. Name calling, fake screen names, giving out personal information, that was the sites modus operandi. We also see a somewhat continuing “Theory” that a group of O.B. Residence may be involved in the deaths of some of the victims as well as helping to cover it up. Which then leads to the accusations and admittance of  some commenters  living in (at least at one time or another)  Oak Beach. While all this seems to much like a movie script, it does actually make it all start to make sense.  So is that really what we got here, a few Oak Beach Neighbors online covering up their involvement in these atrocious crimes. That or the flip-side where you have Oak Beach Residences merely defending their  innocence to a slandering neighbor with an axe to grind, maybe literally.

It would much easier for me to believe that a bunch of “Trolls” were playing games on here, or that Flukeyou or MM7 were some master mind psycho twisting it all, or even what I first read in these comments, that MM7 was on to CPH and he was stalking her. But all of it loses substance when you look at each idea carefully. So weather or not any one from Oak Beach is involved in any murders aside, they seem to definitely be involved in the LISK.site.  Theory, of course. And one we will get into shortly. But Jury Box had a lot more to say, and theories that may not of  sat well with other commenters, especially if they were Oak Beach Residences.

I respect that you have continously tried to solve this case or bring a new outlook
Like yourself, I also am insightful…..but I see JB being the main character. As I stated earlier I recieved a messages which I mentioned. I believe JB attended a big boys party at a young age & I felt as though GC was the sponsor of the girls..I believe JB continued & so did the Doc..

I feel the Doc was supplying the GC mob with high end drugs that a rich customer paid well for. I believe GC probably felt JB was getting reckless & knows they covered up a party gone wrong……

I bet from that time, JB had people wound tightly in his web…..

Why was Gus up & in the bathroom @ that time before 5am…did he just get back from being serviced??? Car show, I highly doubt it….The key man by the gate….What was & is his ROLE??????

More to that picture than one could ever swallow…..

Where did JB take Shannan when she first arrived….The Doc’s???/
For the Sedative Right??????

Is GC, Dr Hackett on Viagra????…..Jb couldn’t get it up…it sounds….used every excuse to get MP out of the area (go to CVS for drugs & lube?)..Why did JB accuse SG of being a male????? Because he couldn’t get erect or get satisfied…. coinsidence a male dressed in womens clothing was found….What could MP say if JB said SG took off upon arrival from CVS???? Nothing..it would have been all on him….But Brilliant Shannan Called 911 & JB already attacked her.. JB put MP on phone.see what caused EVERYTHING FROM THAT POINT ON …. JB SAID HE WAS NOT GOING TO PAY until satisfied……..that is motive, that is why wanted Shannan to finish …that is why JB claimed SG was a male & lastly JB could never be satisfied until the victim was deceased….that’s how SK EVOLVED TO, necrophilia…..this is common……..

So wrongful Death should be as Follows IMO:

JOESPH BREWER, I believe he is the SK, the mastermind, Necrophilia, the person who got Shannan to go to LI

GUS COLLETTI, SG never entered his house which he lied, because he was part of the party if he opened the door Shannan would have pointed him out.

Dr Hackett, who sedated SG, called MG, claimed SG was in his rehab & I believe as stated the Dr gave SG a SEDATIVE

Now 2C2H is insinuating JS junior was the so called DRIFTER….not sure what thats about yet…BUT I do know the Killings started way before he was born.so What is that about???? 2C2H knowing or being Police Officer Neighbor

Now I believe MG should strip all these people of every nickle they may have & the Lawyer should cease any monetary transactions….since the Dr already signed house over to his wife…all should be nil & void if done before Shannan went missing or that opens a suit for the Wife to be sued directly

GO MARI GO!!!!!!
I AM IN SUPPORT OF ANY ACTIONS MAKING THESE KNOWN LIARS responsible for mucking up an INVESTAGATION as well as being part of some type of group cover up/ group crime spree.

Jury Box on January 8th, 2012 at 3:08 pm

Before I go on, I’m not saying that anyone who was sleuthing an Oak beach Resident was bashed, because this is not true, and commenters got in to arguments all the time about different theories. And finger-pointing was done by most of the frequent commenters. But some of these commenters really seemed to rub others wrong and then a routine  seemed to come out. Read these next posts and see if they don’t have a familiarity in them.


jerk box on January 8th, 2012 at 8:20 pm


I am not Kimberly.but I did hit a nerve…so something must be true?????
Now Jerk Box..Ah CADDIE, Fat Man with Pooper scooper????@ the Zoo, how appropriate. When in Roman do as the Romans.

Jury Box on January 9th, 2012 at 6:49 am


jury kim you are psycho. I have even agreed with and supported fluke in the past, but you ignore that completely. You only see what supports your delusions. How do you even know if I’m a man you fool? LE can come over anytime. I have never changed my name. Unlike YOU who have falsely accused, threatened people with false arrest for being people they aren’t and doing what they’ve never done. PSYCHO. I feel very comfortable saying that, as you bear false witness, and do I really need to remind you that what you are doing is harassment, and slander. You wait until you think people are gone, then you start your bullshit over again. I never threatened anyone here. I will not just lie down and take your bullshit.

VeryReal on January 13th, 2012 at 1:37 am


jerkbox, she’s right, she’s not kimberly TODAY anyway!
You are going to hang your foolish head in shame when it all comes out psycho kim, because none of what you imply is true. Why do we have to keep explaining to you that this site has nothing to do with what the investigators think? They aren’t going to change their minds based on some wacko slanderer off their meds accusing Ronald frickin Reagan along with the rest of the world. Didn’t your therapist tell you you aren’t better yet, and have to keep taking the meds?

VeryReal on January 13th, 2012 at 1:44 am


Different Screens Names, but same game. Alright, I think we are about ready to come back to the posts and comments I first read on LISK.com as well as all that has been posted in comments since the site went down. Time to come full circle sort to speak.

Who’s Who?


i am tired of these users using false names,acting crazy under others names.trying to use others names to say stuff that person would not say.please vote here on,making it a 1 user per-name site.and possible a 1 user per ip address site.or 1 user per email address.maybe this will put a halt to the mayhem.
all that agree please vote yes,all that dont agree vote no.
admin. please take this very heavily in your decision.

In this post  Wanda left in  January 2012 on LISK.com, it seems clear that the question of someone using more than one screen name was an ongoing thing on LISK.com:

Just a warning, Jury has been rather quite…
So that means that he is still here… he has just switched screen names….
I’ll have that info shortly….                        

NO WAY!!! on February 7th, 2012 at 10:50 am


@ Jenny,
I can tell you for a fact that Im not Jury……I just started posting here,and somehow I knew this would happen.I hesitated to post here because of so many being accused of posting as someone else….Maybe some are but Im not….And no I dont Live on Long Island,Im over 1500 miles away,but my husband was told that they may get the recovery contract after Irene,and I fallow him,so I was a bit concerned about a serial Killer being on the Loose….. Im just praying that this sick person/s are caught….so that the victums can Rest In Peace..And their familes can have Justice…

SouthernBelle on February 7th, 2012 at 4:07 pm


Mr. Pooper Scooper,
Cappy…..loves caps…Weirdo Hats
You got to be kidding…..Whats your real screen name Very Real???????Barnaby…………Ken??????/Caddie?????

You make me laugh you are a BIG FAKE…..How’s the ZOO life????? Cleaning up Poop all day must get aggravating……so I guess creating a super Hero persona is almost understandable

How about a trailer trash cook book??????? To go with that lifestyle of yours.

The peach fuz chin…..whats that about, Speak of heavy…OMG….Dirty Looking …..Dumpy more like it…..Basically jumped into a dumpster to dress….but nothing fits….real Raunchy

I won’t reveal your license plate or your address like you do to others……You are a discusting FAKE.Go jacuzzi/hot tub your clothes…the stink is unbearable.

You ever here that saying CRACK KILLS……pull up your dumpy Huge jeans as your backside SMELLS. Balding head grasps for straws with tiny side burns & straggly gross strangly chin hair.

If targeting posters putting out peoples private info makes you feel Superior (cuz thats what you do) you get the info from Mari …..using whatever means you can, this is not being a detective…..it’s honestly taking advantage of people with a genuine concern. Why try to inflict fear????? on others, why Caddies Gus Coletti talk as though he is on edge of his porch just waiting to legitimately shoot someone.

This is the atmosphere you & peudeo’s names create….very consistant

Now give the Sight back to the families Mr. Elephant Man…..hoping to get fame & spot light attention from them….You deserve nothing so don’t even start about how important you are.

They may have not noticed you are a LEECH yet….But they will.

To me I see you as a discusting, grave robber…….who thinks everybody owes him….just like the book writer…..Do you know anything about the film someone is trying to make..probably a ploy by Serial Killer…..


Jury Box on January 7th, 2012 at 11:45 am


haha that ones a kook and i would never respond to it!im not new ive been posting for a while now.always under jenny sooooo quite insulting to me if you can even entertain that i am the jury kook.anyway i am one of the minority on this board being that i live here and none of you do.it truly amazes me that there are so many people outside of long island that has taking an intrest to this case.believe me people here could care less!most people i talk to barely knows we have a serial killer right under our noses!!!

jenny on February 7th, 2012 at 7:08 am

So Barnaby Jones  and  Jim (who I’m guessing is Jim Jones) are Fluke supporters. Are they Fluke? And what about jenny? She said she lived there and thanks Truthspider for turning her on to the book supposed to be about CPH’s childhood. Is she Fluke? And what about NO WAY!!! ?

And then on the other side we have mcme. Definitely not a fan of Fluke’s.  Then there are others like The Foreigner. I did not read any posts made by The Foreigner but many comments about them, so they must have ruffled some feathers on one side or the other.

But looking at older posts one commenter seems to not trust ither side, and it didn’t seem like anyone trusted hers. Jury Box…

Caddie YOU ARE LYING!!!!!!!


So stop with the NONSENSE……You are not believed

Nobody on this Sight has a pass card….that is what serail killers look for. Trust from innocent…..NO ONE HERE IS TO BE BELIEVED as to who they are.

People use others identity….try & achieve sending a virus to a poster to track steal passwords, banking & even posting as…..

This sight is a non secured…That Says It All people. You knopw what you are getting into….

Mingling with Residents from Oak Beach & most likely Joesph Brewer The Serial Killer Himself…IMO

So every1 knows the big game on here
Reveal or use screen name….whatever…there are no rules..here

They make them when the crossed a serious boundary than they do not inforce

Jury Box on January 7th, 2012 at 12:16 pm


Wait… now who is Caddie?

Identity Fraud


As I write these blogs, I never know where to censor myself. Especially when it comes to using real names rather than screen names. Obviously others involved have not had a problem with this, so any names I use are already up there, somewhere on the internet to see. (or at least had been up there at one time) But still, I have to question myself before I do. Now part of me is not even sure some of these “names” mentioned are even really the names of people involved in this case or LISK.com. and this is why I choose to use some of these “names”.  Here’s what I mean… Gambino and Scalice are both Mob names, and I’ve seen comments on mob involvement before, but I personally can not say these families lived in Oak Beach, and were apart of this community. Dorothy Hill is a name thrown around as maybe MM7’s real, real identity. PS149 posted this:

Long Island Serial Killer » Blog Archive » ps149
 I do know that it is highly unlikely that he is the “Long Island Serial Killer” responsible for 11 … Mysterymom7 but her real name is D  (name witheld by request).


I actually found that yesterday googling different things, so this shows that even though the site is down there is still stuff floating around in internet space.

I know that the comment is not in its entirerty, but it had included an accusation from PS149 that the phone call MM7 claimed to have made to Jim Jones actually came from some one named D (name withheld by request).  In this comment by PS149, the name is mixed up a little, it would later be D (named witheld as requested), some one MM7 says she know’s but is not her. MM7 says she is Cristin, a name that was thrown out by other posters.  I found Facebook pages for both names and at least at one time they were Facebook friends and both had posted on “Catch The Long Island Killer”, LISK.com’s Facebook Doppelganger. Jim Jones also posted on there.  Now that the page is gone it is hard for me to find Cristin, D (name removed by request), or Jim Jones’ Facebook page, but they are probably set up not to be seen or something, but they were there. Now Jim Jones has been connected to all sorts of Screen Names and if I’m reading new comments right, MM7 now thinks he is writing comments on her blogs and now mine as well using different Screen Names, today it was the SN Evelyn, who is said to be Joey Scalice’s mom. MM7 says Jim Jones’ real name is Michael Dougherty. And that’s the name of a movie director.

So what I’m getting at is, even though all these names have been “leaked”, I have no proof that any of these names are real or at least really anyone involved in these posts.

So I will use them when needed, after all they have already been thrown out there, and not by me. But I am not trying to endanger anyone or use names of people who have nothing to do with this, so feel free to ask me to remove anything that you might feel is fraudulent or personal info of yourself that you do not want out there.

Now let’s get back to Joey…